Friday, 30 June 2017

Miller's Musings Parshas Chukas: When Right is Wrong and Wrong is Right


בס''ד


The unfathomable nature of the Red Heifer and its designation as a chok is not just in the seemingly arcane manner of how such a concoction functioned, but perhaps more crucially in the paradox contained within it.  For although it was able to purify those who had become impure through contact with a corpse, those who prepared it themselves became impure.  This being the epitome of those mitzvos that seem to transcend rationale reason, requires us to contemplate what it is specifically about this particular contradiction that the Torah chose to use and what message is alluded to in its illogicality.

If we were to try and encapsulate the purpose of chokim, those mitzvos of seemingly arbitrary composition, one could suggest it is so that we realise that the reason to fulfil the dictates of the Torah is simply to fulfil the will of Hashem.  The logic of this fulfilment is in effect irrelevant to the fact that G-d has instructed us that it should be so.  This in itself can be a challenging level for us to achieve, as instinctively we seek to understand all that we do.  Yet a task that is even more in opposition to our nature, is to perform acts that we have formerly considered wrong, or to abstain from that which we have always considered desirable.  To do something that the Torah says is right, even when it runs contrary to our own innate sense of morality, conceivably requires an even greater level of faith than something that is merely not in line with our sense of logic.  This perhaps is what is intimated by the notion that within this mitzvo what is pure becomes defiled, and that which is contaminated becomes cleansed.  To truly believe in the perfection of the Torah is if necessary to take that which we considered improper and view it as just and transform those elements we thought of as righteous into a sin.  


Despite claims to the contrary, society today, perhaps more than ever, commands us to think in a certain way, believe in specified notions of morality and only say those things that fit within these confines.  The laws of political correctness govern what we can and cannot say and the right to free speech is applied only as long as we are using it for what they deem acceptable. Respect, kindness and compassion must be shown to all who walk this earth, but it is not society that decides what is right and what is wrong, but the eternal Torah given to us by G-d.  It is indeed hard to put aside the ideals we have long held sacrosanct, yet at times it may be what is necessitated by the sublimity of our Law. 

*May the brilliance of Shabbos help us to see with absolute clarity*
                                                                                                                          
לעילוי נשמת לאה בת אברהם



לרפואה שלימה:  שרה יעל בת ברכה אסתר

No comments:

Post a Comment

Please let me know if you enjoyed this week's Musings or if you have any other comments that you would like to make about the ideas discussed. I would love to hear from you.